Personal Statement Concerning Bishop Megan Rohrer 

I celebrated the election of Pastor Megan Rohrer as the first openly Transgendered bishop within the Church-at-Large, even though I had not voted for them. As the pastor of an open and affirming congregation that acted 25 years ago to stand alongside of brothers and sisters who were members of what was called the LGBT community at that time, I joyfully announced their election to my congregation on the Sunday following the Synod Assembly.

            Over the past year, however, many of the actions taken by Bishop Rohrer have caused me to assess what was taking place within the SPS. Something just wasn’t right. Admittedly, I was bothered by the (seemingly constant) seeking of personal publicity by Bishop Rohrer. I found nothing of value in their insipid Weekly Prayers or their banal Book Studies or their trite reports of where they worshipped on a weekly basis. But this was all stylistic and I realized that every SPS Bishop has brought a distinctive character to the office.

            Of more concern were the things I began hearing about actions taken by Bishop Rohrer during their tenure at Grace Lutheran Church and with regard to their current interactions with their staff and congregations (Mision Latina Luterana and others), as well as their handling of the allegations concerning Pastor Nelson Rabell-Gonzales.

            I must question why the actions of Pastor Rohrer, while at Grace Lutheran Church, were not disclosed to the Synod Assembly in 2021. I believe that if the actions and the subsequent court cases had been revealed it would have changed the outcome of the election for bishop. I think it highly possible, if not probable, that at least one member of the assembly would have switched their vote and we would have had another result.

            Beyond that, however, I think that the actions of Pastor Rohrer during their tenure at Grace Lutheran Church rise to a level that certainly calls for disciplinary action to be taken.

            As I have read increasingly about the actions taken against Pastor Rabell-Gonzales, as a result of allegations that do not appear to have ever been subjected to a proper disciplinary process, I have come to realize that there is an issue beyond Pastor Rabell-Gonzales’ guilt or innocence. The issue is the manner in which Bishop Rohrer managed this situation. Their actions disregarded staff advise, violated the sanctity of the Mision Latina Luterana congregation, and exhibited an attitude of white supremacy and racism which is unbelievable.

            I know that some will try to drag “red herrings” across this concern and that moot questions will be asked, but this situation is not about anything but the actions of Bishop Megan Rohrer. I passionately believe that the matter of Grace Lutheran Church should have been revealed at the previous Synod Assembly and that the actions of Megan Rohrer since being installed as SPS Bishop rise to the level of demanding disciplinary action.

            For the good of the church they must either resign or be removed from office, so that we can move beyond this situation and begin to wrestle with the systemic racism that affects our entire denomination.


Reverend John L. Freesemann

Holy Redeemer Lutheran Church

May 23, 2022


June 29, 2022

WHEREAS further disclosure and transparency concerning the reasons for the closure of Grace Lutheran Church in San Francisco are needed, particularly as this pertains to the pastorate of Pastor Megan Rohrer; and

WHEREAS it appears that a full disclosure of the litigation in which Pastor Rohrer and Grace Lutheran Church were involved to the Members of the Sierra Pacific Synod in Assembly might well have resulted in a different election result when Pastor Megan Rohrer was elected as Bishop of the Sierra Pacific Synod; and

WHEREAS Bishop Rohrer exhibited a lack of Christian grace, toward their staff and Pastor Nelson Rabell-Gonzalez, in the handling of the issues surrounding Pastor Nelson Rabell-Gonzalez and the congregation of Mision Latina Luterana (now known as Iglesia Santa Maria Peregrina); now, therefore be it

RESOLVED, until such time as these issues are addressed by the National Expression of the ELCA, and either rectified or refuted, and notification given to the church-at-large, Holy Redeemer American Lutheran Church of San Jose:

  • will not participate in Sierra Pacific Synod meetings/assemblies; and
  • will not remit any contributions for the direct support of the Sierra Pacific Synod; and
  • will continue to monitor the situation in the SPS and research cogent questions in order to make a further decision.

Passed Unanimously

Holy Redeemer American Lutheran Church

San Jose, CA

Special Congregational Meeting

April 24, 2022


Celebration & Communion




Holy Redeemer Lutheran Church

is a

NAMI - Santa Clara County

Mental Health Friendly

Stigma Free

Faith Community




Holy Redeemer Lutheran Church

is a

Reconciling in Christ Congregation



About Holy Redeemer:

Meet Pastor Freesemann, and visit the About Us section to learn about our pastor and about our congregation!


Join Us!

If you're curious about an Openly Progressive, Permission Giving Community, Looking to the 21st Century with Vision and Hope, then you should come to the Join Us section to learn more. We hope you will join us.



Amazon Smile for web

Go to, sign up with Holy Redeemer Lutheran Church (San Jose) as your charity of choice and a portion of every Amazon purchase you make on amazon smile will come back to the church — at no cost to you!

What could be easier!

Thank you!



Members Login

Last month June 2022 Next month
week 22 1 2 3 4
week 23 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
week 24 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
week 25 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
week 26 26 27 28 29 30